Northern Rocky Mountain GrottoMontana & Wyoming · NSS

Cave Geology at the Heart of the Bob

Hans BodenhamerAGM 2023May 202326 min
659 views 10 likes Counts nrmg.org and YouTube together.
Comments

Hans Bodenhamer explains the geology behind the caves of the Bob Marshall Wilderness: the Cambrian limestones they form in, the Continental Divide Syncline, what shapes the passages, and how glaciers decided where the caves are.

Transcript

0:01 I guess I'll start. I was asked to give a talk on the cave-related geology of the Bob Marshall Wilderness Area, and to be honest, I hadn't really given this subject much thought in a bunch of years, so I might have oversimplified some things. If there are some questions as we go, feel free. And if it gets too complicated, I'll defer you some to questions at the end. This is a picture of me and Doug Powell in the early 1980s at the entrance of Moonray Cave on the South Cirque of Silvertip Peak. It was at this point in my life that I'd finally realized that the best caves were in limestone. Prior to this, in my teenage years, I was not only looking for love in all the wrong places, I was looking for caves in all the wrong places. As Doug and I would move from the North Cirque to the South Cirque, we'd cross this pass and I'd look down into the Bob Marshall Wilderness and I'd just see all this wonderful limestone. I thought, man, there must be caves everywhere. Well, it turns out that at that point in my life, I didn't realize that not all limestones are created equally. Much later, in the late 1990s, we started looking for caves in the Bob Marshall Wilderness, and at this point, I was a lot paunchier, so I wasn't able to fit into some of the tighter caves, and I had a lot more time to think about why the caves are there and why they are the way they are.

1:45 And most of the information for this talk comes from some research that I did in the early 2000s.

1:58 Just to give you an idea where we're talking about,

2:05 this is the center of the Bob Marshall Wilderness, which ends up having the highest density of known caves in the state, and that's where this talk focuses on. This is a Google image of the same area, give you a little orientation. Flathead Lake's right here, Kalispell up here. This would be Silvertip Peak, and Scapegoat Plateau down here. It turns out this whole hunk of land here used to sit somewhere over here and slid this way and when it came to rest it created a bunch of faults along the front here, faults along the back, and this middle part, which I'm going to concentrate on, was bent into a big U shape. I'll talk a little bit more about that structure later, but first a little bit on the cave forming rock layers. I'm having some challenges with this clicker. This is a 3D map that one of my students created for the Center of the Bob Marshall Wilderness. If you notice over here, there's some stars next to the key. The darker the star is, the better it is at forming caves. I'm going to go into each one of the rock layers that form caves just a little bit, but before I go there, Oh, wait a minute, not before I go there. You'll notice on this map that you can see, this would be Turtlehead Mountain area, and this is Silvertip Peak.

3:37 There's some layers that just have a ton of caves, and there's some layers that don't have any, and there's some that have a few. I'll go into each one of the good cave forming layers in just a moment but before that and I know this has got probably too small a print for you to see, but this is a strat column for most all of the rocks in the Bob Marshall Wilderness Area. Just to give you kind of an overview of the way that works and sort of a real general understanding of the geology, limestone, as you all know, is a good cave former. The water flows through cracks, enlarging the cracks through solution, where in contrast, Shale's just horrible. It doesn't really let the water flow through, consequently it doesn't form caves. On the strat column here, on the right side, you'll notice how the profile on the limestones is kind of straight. In the Bob Marshall Wilderness area, most of the limestones are going to form cliffs, whereas the shales, which are drawn with horizontal lines, have dents in them because they're slope formers. You'll notice that some of the limestones, in contrast, actually have dents in them, and some of the limestones in the Bob Marshall Wilderness actually include a lot of shale inside of them, which you would think maybe would make them not as good of cave formers, but that isn't necessarily the case.

5:08 I'm going to take a little trip through each one of the good cave forming layers real quick, starting at the youngest layers. Youngest exposed good cave forming layers in the Bob Marshall Wilderness Area are the Mississippian aged limestones. In the Bob Marshall Wilderness Area, I think these are called the Castle Reef Dolomite and the Allan Mountain Formation. On this colored map, they're the light blue here and here. In other parts of the state, these are equivalent to the Mission Canyon Formation, which are really terrific cave formers in the Little Belt Mountains, the Pryor Mountains, and other places. In the Bob Marshall Wilderness, they're good cave formers. However, there's not a lot of this Mississippian-aged limestone in the Bob Marshall. This is sort of a little sliver of that stuff that's on Silvertip Peak here. As far as I know, in this little hunk of Mississippian-aged limestone, there aren't a lot of extensive or known caves. This is off looking towards the south from the saddle between the North and South Cirque of Silvertip Peak, and there's a really nice hunk of that Mississippian-aged limestone on Lone Butte. This has about a dozen known caves on it. One of them is a really impressive 285-foot-deep pit. There might be a few more, but once again, that's kind of a small, limited hunk of limestone. Next youngest age of good cave forming rock, and this is the really good one, is the Devonian Jefferson limestone, which harbors Silvertip system and the Moonray Daddy Croc system and some caves on the Flathead Alps.

6:58 On this map, it's drawn in tan. And interestingly, and I'm not absolutely sure about this, but Newell Campbell told me that there's really only one other good place in the state that this makes good caves, and that's down by Dillon, where it creates the French Creek Cave. Looking in at Silvertip Peak, you can see the hunk of Devonian Jefferson limestone. Huh, I forgot the T. Interestingly, and I didn't, my student didn't put this on the colored map, this would be the Mississippian Age limestone here, and there's actually a Devonian-aged layer of rock here called the Three Forks Formation, which consists of kind of thin beds of limestone and shale, and there's a few caves in that, but none of them are very big or very deep. This is kind of the caver's wet dream. As you stand there on the pass between the North and South Cirque, you can see all this Devonian Jefferson limestone. Recently, Dustin has found a lot of incredible caves on that plateau right in front there on the South Cirque. There's an apron that surrounds Lone Butte that's also to some extent explored, but there's a lot of good stuff that's going to be probably discovered there in the future. And beyond that, not marked on the map, is some more Jefferson limestone over there by Junction Mountain. Going a little deeper, the next set of limestones are the Cambrian-age limestones.

8:34 These include the Steamboat limestone, which is drawn in teal, the Pagoda limestone, which is purple, and the Dearborn limestone, which is lavender. Start with the Dearborn. It's a really nice, pure limestone. It has some really, really nice caves in it in other parts of the state. I think this is equivalent to what's called the Meagher limestone, which is where Mill Creek Crystal Cave is in. I'm not sure about other places in the state, but it does have some caves near the Beanhole area, but not Beanhole itself. So it is a good cave former in other parts of the state. The Pagoda limestone, on the other hand, includes a lot of small shale layers and for some reason which I think I'll try to explain later it forms good caves in the Bob Marshall Wilderness area, but I don't think it does so good in other parts of the state, although I might not know that for sure. The Steamboat limestone, which you can see only shows one little cave here, has a lot of sort of thin limestone shale beds kind of interspersed with each other, and it forms some caves, but almost all of them are fairly small and not very deep.

9:59 This I didn't really feel like separated them all out, but this would be the Cambrian limestones underneath Silvertip Peak. There's a lot of potential for some stuff there. I think people haven't really walked a lot of that too well. This is looking straight on at Turtlehead Mountain, and it kind of separates out the different Cambrian Age limestones. The Steamboat limestone here, just a little sliver, you can see kind of a hunk of limestone and then a sloping forming layer for the shale. Below that's the Pagoda limestone which forms a really dramatic cliff, but there's a little hunk of floppy shale below it. Dearborn limestone, once again, forms a really nice cliff. Below that's the Damnation limestone, and I don't know of any caves in the Damnation limestone, and below that is the Flathead sandstone, which I don't think is going to have any caves in it. Looking off down the Chinese Wall area, you can see it's topped by the Steamboat limestone with the Pagoda limestone and the Dearborn limestone below it. There are a bunch of little small caves on the top of the Steamboat up there, and then on the face of the Chinese Wall, there are a number of big cave entrances. I know some of them have explored but I don't think any of the ones that have been explored have gone very deep but there's still some others to look at.

11:30 That's pretty much on the rock layers. Going to talk a little bit about the structure in the area. Probably a review for most of you, but the layers are bent into a big U, which is called a syncline. And in the Bob Marshall area, it's called formerly the Continental Divide Syncline.

11:58 I'm not enjoying this mic, I got to tell you. So in any event, just to review this for you, if you don't recall, a syncline is where the rock layers are built into a U like this. At the bottom of the U is what's called the axis, and on either side are the limbs. This diagram here shows sort of a Google Earth image and then I simplified it over here to show sort of where the axis is located and some other interesting things about the axis. Turns out that the Continental Divide Syncline is not only built into a U, this is probably the high point of the whole talk, it actually porpoises up and down like this.

12:45 Where it goes from going up to going down is called a hinge point. And where it's going, well, they're all hinge points. There are several hinge points on the axis there, and they're shown as blue dots on there. Where the axis goes away from the hinge point on both places, there's sort of a narrow expression of the syncline, and where it goes towards the hinge point at both places, it gets quite a bit deeper. The main effect of where these hinge points are located is going to determine the maximum depth that caves like Tears of the Turtle, Virgil Cave, and even the Silvertip system is going to attain. Another interesting thing about the axis and its location is you'll notice that it's quite a bit closer to the west side than the east side and the reason for this is it's not symmetrical. It's bent in sort of a Nike swoosh shape. So on the west side of the syncline, it's dissected by a bunch of drainages, and there's a bunch of flathead or flatiron-type buttresses, which you can see in that kind of zoomed-in thing there. The effect of this in terms of cave formation, and this is looking straight on at Turtlehead Mountain, is these down-trending drainages expose the layers sort of in U's that the water can then get into the limestone easier to form caves.

14:24 Whereas in contrast, on the east side of the syncline, it's capped by the Steamboat limestone all the top, and there's hardly any drainages that dissect it, making it harder for it to get into the Pagoda and Dearborn limestone, which seem to be better cave formers. Enough big structure, going to go into a few quirks of geology that shape and kind of place the caves. One of the really striking things about Virgil Cave is the huge cross sections of the passage. Passages are typically 100 feet wide and 40 feet tall, and they go like that for over a mile down a steep passageway. In contrast, most all the other caves in the Turtlehead Mountain area are steep, tight canyon passages that are kind of miserable to negotiate. This set of cross sections shows sort of a comparison of some of the caves in the area. This is Virgil Cave, that's about 100 feet across there. Tears of the Turtle, Cave That Summer Forgot, Tickle Me Turtle Cave, and Love Lost Caves, all dramatically different from the shape of the cross sections in Virgil Cave. Whoops. An explanation of why the cross sections in Virgil Cave are so big, it kind of helps to look at where the cave is situated in terms of the different subunits of the Pagoda Limestone.

15:57 This is where the profile of Virgil Cave runs, and it's quite a bit developed in subunit 2, but it also goes into the lowest unit, which is subunit 1. If you look at that on the surface, you can see that if you can imagine, this is Virgil Cave entrance. This is the lowest subunit, and the cave extends kind of along this direction here, staying at that pretty much same elevation in the Pagoda. What's going on there is this one has a whole lot more shale in it and that's why it forms a slope, where these are more limestone. They still have quite a bit of shale in them, but they've got a lot more limestone in them. In Virgil Cave, actually the first few hundred feet of passage are a steep, narrow, tight canyon passage, but when it breaks into the Aurora Room, it goes from subunit 1 to subunit 2. So as the passage was being cut through there, what it wanted to do in subunit 1 was form a slope but it couldn't create a slope that went outward so the slope went inward. And as it was cut deeper and deeper into subunit 1, this would cause the ceiling, which was subunit 2, to collapse into the cave, causing the wider and wider passages. I hope that makes sense. Another interesting factor are the caves in the Turtlehead Mountain area, and these are called rose diagrams.

17:32 What they do is they plot the trend of surveyed passages in the cave. You can see that a lot of the passages are going right down the bed dip, which would be going down the dip of the syncline limb. So this would be Virgil Cave, and it's going a little bit off when it hits the strike of a thrust fault. Here's Tears of the Turtle Cave, almost all going straight down the dip of the limestone. Here's Love Lost Cave. These three caves are in the Pagoda, and they're almost all diving down that dip, whereas these that are in the Dearborn have a little bit more variation, but they still seem to really like to go down that dip. Just to kind of emphasize that a little bit more, these are the entrances to Tickle Me Turtle Cave. If you can imagine the cave kind of being connected between these dots, it pretty much stays in that same elevation of the Pagoda Limestone. This is a profile of Love Lost Cave, and once again, the roof is almost sandwiched between these two different things, so it's staying at the same elevation in that particular limestone. What might have happened when these caves were forming forming, is there was one particularly extremely permeable layer that geologists have called an inception horizon, and the water was able to enter that layer and flow down that layer almost straight down the dip as it initially started to form the cave instead of maybe forming more vertical joints or something like that.

19:14 You can, oh this would be one last thing about some interesting features of the way the cave is. Whenever the caves in the Dearborn or the Turtlehead Mountain area cross a thrust fault, they either follow the thrust fault for a little bit like down here, or they make a pit. This diagram shows how pits might have formed in that situation if they were following an inception horizon. The water would have been pretty much filling the whole passage going like this. When it hits the thrust fault, it backs back underneath and then trends back down the inception horizon. More solution would enlarge that quite a bit, creating this large overhang which eventually would collapse and create a pit. Last thing I'm going to talk about a little bit is the placement of these caves and how successive glacial advances would have affected where these caves are located. Initially, and this is maybe a little controversy, I think the caves probably formed prior to glaciation underneath some steep, tight canyons, as in the first diagram. As the glaciers came into the area, they would have widened the valleys out, making them more bowl-shaped. And successive glaciations, by the way, I forgot to mention this, the geologists place there being four major glacial advances during the Pleistocene era, but in the northern part, northern latitudes, at high altitudes, some geologists suggest that there might have been as many as nine glacial advances.

20:54 So there's a lot of this sort of reshaping the valleys as they go. Anyways, progressive glacial advances, what happens is the glacier starts to erode the north side more dramatically because the glacier doesn't melt as fast on the north side and you get these steep cliffs on the north side and more of a sloping side or sloping expression on the south side. The effect of this would have been in the Turtlehead Mountain area is the caves are now located more or less not under the drainages, but underneath the ridges, and the entrances are left hanging on the walls of cliffs. You can kind of see the shape of the valleys left by the glaciers in this picture. Here would be the sloping south-facing slopes of the valley, and here's the steep north face. Interestingly, you can see the snow lingering underneath that north face as with the glaciers would have.

21:58 Some of the passages seem to trend a little bit underneath the valleys in the area and I think this might have happened when it first started dissecting the valleys. It might have connected passages that went from one valley to another. As the glaciers eroded that out, there'd just be remnants of these valley passages left. If you look at the map at Double Date Cave, if you can imagine going from left to right, this is heading down the dip of the syncline, or the dip of the syncline limb, and this would be heading across it. These would be the passages that these passages here might have been the passages that were formed when the canyons were first cut connecting one canyon to another. This is a profile that looks across the syncline limb, accentuating the passages that are going down the dip of the syncline limb. If you look at those passages, almost all of them are canyon-shaped. Whereas in contrast, passages that go...

23:18 This is a profile that looks down the dip of the syncline. So passages that are going down the dip would be more horizontal like this, or they'd be almost vertical, and these would be the ones that are going across the syncline limb. Passages that go across the syncline limb, in contrast, have more of a phreatic shape, as if they were filled with water, maybe as the cave was first forming. This is a picture. I'm going to end it up here, just talking a little bit of what might happen in the Silvertip area. In the Turtlehead Mountain area, the caves are located more on the limb of the the syncline, where in the Silvertip area, they're almost all on the axis of the syncline. So if you can imagine this period where they were formed phreatically, where they're forming those rounder passages, and then later on it cuts a canyon in them, it would superimpose these type of passages on top of each other. Maybe these near-the-axis passages represent different elevations controlled by glacial drains. And these glacial drains might have been the phreatic passages like this that were later cut by canyons. Kind of wild speculation. Be kind of neat to map those out and then actually date some formations to see if we could figure out some sort of evolutionary history for the caves in the Silvertip area.

24:54 Good ones to date wouldn't be those ones I just showed in the other picture. They'd be some more massive ones that have been undercut by streams. That's pretty much it. I just thought I'd show a picture of Flathead Alps Cave to close it. Flathead Alps Cave cuts almost all the way through the Devonian Jefferson limestone. I'm not entirely sure why it does that. In the area, there's just lots of cool-looking limestone. We spent a little bit of time there, found a few caves, but there's a lot to find. So hopefully that inspires you to go out looking. And thanks for listening.

Comments

Nobody has said anything yet. Were you on the trip, or in the room? Say what the talk leaves out, or put a time in your comment (like 23:10) and it becomes a link to that moment.


An officer reads new comments before they appear. Sign in and yours goes up straight away.